The Panthers have a difficult audition process involving stealing a valuable item and delivering it to Woodford. Boothe wants to steal the twin of the Hope Diamond for his audition but Neal comes up with a better plan; break into Wordford's office and leave something in his secret safe.
Matthew Keller is also shown to be a newer member of the Panthers. Keller joined the Panthers while working for Interpol. Neal discovered Keller was working for Interpol in the episode Return to Sender. Interpol inserted a chip under the skin of Kellers wrist, leaving a painful scar and constant itching in his wrist.